Weirdly Cited

Does a sloth grow a garden in its own fur, fertilized by moths that breed in its poop?

Proposed.

Three-toed sloths climb down to defecate about once a week. Pregnant moths leave them to lay eggs in fresh dung, while algae make up most of their fur's microbial biomass; the authors propose that sloths graze the algae, but the alga turned up in only some sloths' stomachs, nobody saw them eat it, and a published critique disputes it.

Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it

C1: A weekly descent to defecate

Three-toed sloths climb down their tree about once a week to poop, which is risky and costly.

A three-toed sloth will, however, descend its tree weekly to defecate, which is risky, energetically costly and, until now, inexplicable.

Source: Abstract.

C2: Predator deaths near the ground

More than half of the adult sloth deaths the team documented were predator kills at or near the ground.

more than one-half of all adult sloth mortalities we have documented were depredation events when sloths were at or near the ground

Source: Introduction.

C3: An 8% daily-energy estimate

The team estimates the climb down costs about 8% of a sloth's daily energy budget.

the average cost of descending from the canopy to defecate constitutes approximately 8% of a sloth's daily energetic budget

Source: Introduction.

C4: Pregnant moths leave to lay eggs

Pregnant female sloth moths leave the sloth and lay eggs in the fresh dung.

gravid female moths leave the sloth and oviposit in the fresh excrement

Source: Introduction.

C5: More moths on three-toed sloths

They vacuumed an average of 15.2 moths off each three-toed sloth (up to 39) versus 4.5 off two-toed sloths.

On average, we collected 15.2 (±2.9; range = 4–39) and 4.5 (±1.3; range = 0–21) moths from three- and two-toed sloths, respectively

Source: Methods.

C6: Algae make up most fur microbes

The team estimates the average sloth carries about 125.5 g of microbial growth, mostly algae, in its fur: about 2.6% of its body mass.

harbour 125.5 g (±14.8 g, ±1 s.e.) of microbial biomass (principally algae) in their fur, which translates into approximately 2.6% (±0.2%) of their body mass

Source: Results and discussion.

C7: Fur algae had more lipid

The fur algae had 3 to 5 times more fat (lipid) than the leaves sloths eat.

microalgae were three to five times richer in lipid content

Source: Results and discussion.

C8: Alga in some stomach samples

Trichophilus, an alga known only from sloth fur, turned up in stomach samples from 2 of 12 three-toed sloths (17%) and 6 of 16 two-toed sloths (38%).

we identified Trichophilus spp. in the digesta of two of the three-toed sloths (or 17%) and six of the two-toed sloths sampled (or 38%)

Source: Results and discussion.

C9: Cow microbes in the digestibility test

The digestibility test used rumen microbes from two dairy cows, not sloth gut microbes.

The inoculum was composited from two Holstein dairy cows

Source: Methods.

C10: The algae-garden proposal

The authors propose that sloths graze 'algae gardens' grown through a three-way mutualism of sloths, moths and algae.

we propose that sloths are grazing the ‘algae-gardens’ they have derived from a three-way mutualism

Source: Conclusion.

What the study doesn't say

The model remains a proposal. The authors call for experiments to test its links; their paper offers clues, not proof of the whole cycle.

The moth, nitrogen and algae links are correlations: sloths with more moths had more nitrogen in their fur, and more nitrogen went with more algae.

Trichophilus appeared in digestive material from 2 of 12 three-toed sloths and 6 of 16 two-toed sloths. The researchers did not observe sloths eating the algae. The paper suggests sloths take it in through autogrooming.

The digestibility test used rumen microbes from two Holstein dairy cows, not sloth gut microbes. Fur and moth samples came from 19 three-toed and 14 two-toed adult sloths at one site in Costa Rica in August 2012; the paper does not say when the stomach samples were taken.

A 2021 published critique by Monge-Najera rejects the mutualism model. It points to no observations of sloths licking themselves or each other, and no reports of moths fertilizing the algae. It also argues that sloths cannot reach most of their own fur, that the few stomach detections could come from the same algae growing on leaves they eat, and that the cow-microbe test ignores differences between cow and sloth guts. It proposes that ground defecation may persist from ground-dwelling ancestors. This is a literature-based critique, not a new experiment.

The source

Pauli, J. N., Mendoza, J. E., Steffan, S. A., Carey, C. C., Weimer, P. J., and Peery, M. Z. "A syndrome of mutualism reinforces the lifestyle of a sloth." Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 281(1778), 20133006 (2014).

DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2013.3006.

Full text at PubMed Central. It is free to read, but not under a Creative Commons licence. No figures are reproduced here.

The critique: Monge-Najera, J. (2021). "Why sloths defecate on the ground: rejection of the mutualistic model." UNED Research Journal, 13(1). DOI: 10.22458/urj.v13i1.3438.

The Short

Watch it on YouTube: https://youtu.be/dD2bpV6vjeE