Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it
C1: Stressed plants gave off airborne sounds
Stressed tomato and tobacco plants gave off airborne sounds. The researchers could record them from a distance and sort them with a computer.
stressed plants emit airborne sounds that can be recorded from a distance and classified
Source: Summary.
C2: The sounds were ultrasonic
The recordings focused on ultrasound: 20 to 150 kHz. You cannot hear these sounds directly.
We focused on the ultrasonic sound range (20–150 kHz)
Source: Results.
C3: Dry tomatoes averaged about 35 sounds an hour
Drought-stressed tomatoes made about 35 sounds an hour on average. For tobacco, it was about 11.
The mean number of sounds emitted by dry plants was 35.4 ± 6.1 and 11.0 ± 1.4 per hour for tomato and tobacco, respectively
Source: Results.
C4: Control plants averaged fewer than one
The control groups averaged fewer than one sound an hour.
the mean number of sounds emitted by plants from all the control groups was lower than 1 per hour
Source: Results.
C5: Tomato sounds rose, then fell
As tomatoes went without water, their daily sound count rose over the next 4 to 5 days, then fell as they dried out. More drying did not mean more sounds all the way through.
the number of sounds per day increases in the following 4–5 days, and then the number of sounds decreases as the plant dries up
Source: Results.
C6: About 70% accuracy telling drought from cutting
Software could tell drought stress from cutting by sound alone with about 70% accuracy. It could get the answer wrong.
with an accuracy of 70% using supervised machine learning methods
Source: Discussion.
C7: The sounds told dry plants from controls in a greenhouse
The sounds also let the researchers distinguish drought-stressed plants from watered controls in a greenhouse.
distinguishing between drought-stressed and control plants in a greenhouse, based only on the sounds they emit
Source: Discussion.
C8: Measured at 10 cm: around 61-66 decibels
Measured 10 cm from dry plants, mean peak sound intensity was around 61-66 decibels. The authors treat these measurements as lower bounds because the microphones were directional.
The mean peak sound intensity recorded from dry plants was 61.6 ± 0.1 dBSPL and 65.6 ± 0.4 dBSPL at 10 cm, for tomato and tobacco, respectively
Source: Results.
C9: Animal hearing range was an estimate
The authors estimate that some mammals and insects could detect the sounds from 3 to 5 metres away. That distance came from hearing sensitivity; this study did not test animals listening to plants.
could be detected from a distance of 3–5 m, by many mammals and insects
Source: Discussion.
C10: Air bubbles in the stem could explain some sounds
Cavitation in the stem could explain at least some of the sounds: air bubbles forming in the tissue that carries water. The researchers did not settle the mechanism.
One potential mechanism that may be responsible for the emission of at least part of the sounds we record is cavitation in the stem
Source: Discussion.
What the study doesn't say
"Screaming" would add something the paper does not show. It reports mechanical sound emission. Cavitation is a possible cause of at least part of it, and the authors describe their understanding of the mechanism as "still rudimentary" in Limitations.
The clicks are ultrasonic. The paper's audio was converted into the audible range and compressed in time. The Short does not play any plant sound.
The 3 to 5 metre range is an estimate from animal hearing sensitivity. The paper did not test whether a moth or mouse actually heard a plant.
Most of the work used tomato and tobacco in an acoustic box or a greenhouse. The authors say field recording "would present additional challenges". Their small survey also recorded wheat, corn, grapevine, pincushion cactus and henbit; almond and the woody parts of grapevine produced no recordings. This is not a result for every plant in every setting.
The acoustic-box groups had 19 to 51 plants each. The longer greenhouse run used 23 tomatoes. Classification accuracy depended on the task: about 70% for dry versus cut, about 84% for dry versus watered in the greenhouse, and 81% for high versus low dehydration.
The decibel figures are lower bounds because the microphones were directional. They do not tell you how loud a plant would sound to your ears.
The source
Khait I et al. "Sounds emitted by plants under stress are airborne and informative." Cell 186(7):1328-1336.e10, 30 March 2023.
DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2023.03.009.
Publisher full text. The quotes on this page were checked against an archived copy of the publisher page, because the publisher pages returned an access error.
Open-access licence: CC BY 4.0.
The Short
Watch it on YouTube: https://youtu.be/6YoXwU6GOpg