Before Atlanta, Emory's own report says, the collection sat in a dark and dusty second-floor room atop Niagara Falls' Daredevil Hall of Fame. That museum's story starts with one man, a staircase and a small taxidermy collection.
This page follows the Niagara Falls Museum from Thomas Barnett's founding to the 1999 sale, from the record: an 1859 parliamentary report, the University of Toronto's finding aid for the museum's own papers, an 1860 notice, an 1872 newspaper letter, and the buyer's records.
The record, beat by beat
Thomas Barnett and the founding
Thomas Barnett, born in 1799, came to Canada from Birmingham, England, in 1824. He lived first in Kingston, then in Niagara Falls.
"Thomas Barnett (1799-1890) emigrated to Canada from Birmingham, England in 1824, residing first in Kingston and then in Niagara"
The museum dates its founding to 1827. The finding aid for its papers calls it Canada's oldest museum, first opened that year. The 1859 select committee put its age at about twenty-five years.
"Barnett was the founder and proprietor of Canada's oldest museum, which first opened in 1827"
"The Niagara Falls Museum has been established about twenty-five years"
It began small, mostly taxidermy, Barnett's main hobby.
"collection, composed chiefly of Barnett's main hobby, taxidermy"
The falls brought the visitors. The price of admission included Barnett's tour down the staircase at Table Rock and behind the falls.
"at Table Rock and behind the falls, which was included with the price of admission, brought tourists to the museum"
The papers hold certificates for passing behind the falling sheet of water to Termination Rock, signed by Thomas Barnett. The finding aid's date column for them begins in July 1850.
"Water to Termination Rock. Provided by the Register Office, Table Rock and signed by Thomas Barnett"
Source: Niagara Falls Museum Papers finding aid, administrative history and series 1; 1859 select-committee report, p.1.
How the collection grew
Between 1850 and 1867 the collection grew from 10,000 specimens to over 100,000, mainly through Thomas's son Sydney, born in 1836. The finding aid's history spells the son Sydney; its series headings and letters spell Sidney.
"from 10,000 specimens to over 100,000 between 1850 and 1867, primarily due to Thomas' son, Sydney (1836-1925)"
Sydney collected oddities. He travelled to Egypt to bring back mummies, in 1854 and 1857 by the finding aid's count, and he started a specimen exchange with other museums.
"Sydney collected oddities and anthropological collections, including traveling to Egypt to bring back mummies in 1854 and 1857"
The papers also list a form letter from the Smithsonian Institution asking for specimens of native mammals. The finding aid's date column sets 1857 near it, but its layout does not pair the two cleanly.
"Form letter from the Smithsonian Institution requesting specimens of native mammals with directives on"
Source: Niagara Falls Museum Papers finding aid, administrative history and series 1.
What parliament found inside, 1859
In 1859 a select committee of the Legislative Assembly of the Province of Canada examined Thomas Barnett's petition. Its task was to report how far his museum had advanced natural history, and how far science would gain if he could trade Canadian specimens for those of other countries.
"to report how far the Museum of the Petitioner has contributed to promote the knowledge of Natural History in Canada and on the Continent of America"
The committee counted about 150 native Canadian birds and 175 mammals.
"It contains about one hundred and fifty native Canadian birds, from the humming bird to the eagle"
"One hundred and seventy-five mammals, comprising the different varieties, from the smallest mouse to the elk and moose"
It counted 490 foreign birds and 38 foreign mammals, a Barbary lion among them.
"Four hundred and ninety specimens of foreign birds"
"Thirty-eight foreign mammals, among which there is a fine Barbary lion"
It listed over 8,000 insects, and a coin collection that Barnett called the finest in America. That last part is Barnett's claim, as the committee reported it.
"In Entomology there is a fine collection, numbering over eight thousand specimens"
"There is a collection of ancient and modern coins, from the most remote periods, which Mr. Barnett represents to be the finest in America"
The Egyptian antiquities in 1859 included two mummies and the remains of others.
"a great variety of Egyptian antiquities, amongst which are two mummies and the remains of others"
There were the remains of two mastodons, and one tusk measured nine feet.
"There are the remains of two specimens of the gigantic mastodon, which are particularly interesting; the tusk of one measures nine feet in length"
Some of the animals were alive, including a male and a female buffalo that Barnett had kept for fifteen years.
"There are also several specimens of living animals, among which are two buffaloes, male and female, which Mr. Barnett has had for fifteen years"
Professor Hincks told the committee some of Barnett's Canadian specimens beat what he had managed to get for the University of Toronto's museum.
"greatly exceeding in some instances what he himself had been able by great exertion and expense to procure for the Museum of the University of Toronto, under his care"
Source: Report of the select committee on the petition of Thomas Barnett, 1859, pp.1-2.
The petition and the committee's answer
A ticket cost twenty-five cents. A witness, Routh, put the past year's visitors at close to twenty thousand.
"at a charge of twenty-five cents for each ticket of admission"
"The number of visitors during the last year could not have fallen far short of twenty thousand"
Another witness, Couper, read the museum's register of visitors and found most of the names were from foreign countries.
"I found the greater majority to be composed of persons from foreign countries"
Teachers and pupils of all schools got in free.
"It is a standing rule to admit the teachers and pupils of all schools free"
Routh said Barnett had his son collecting in Egypt, and spent every farthing on the collection or his grounds.
"Mr. Barnett has had his son in Egypt, and other parts of the old world, collecting and sending home curiosities and antiquities of the most valuable description"
"he expends every farthing he receives in either enlarging his collection or beautifying his grounds"
The report also records that Barnett gave admission money to relief after the 1845 Quebec fires, which destroyed 1,800 buildings.
"the houseless and destitute in the City of Quebec, upon the occasion of the calamitous fires by which 1800 buildings were destroyed in 1845"
The grievance was trade. Routh named a difficulty Barnett had met and in several instances failed to overcome: procuring exchanges from museums supported by, or receiving, government aid or protection.
"it is the difficulty of procuring exchanges from other museums supported by, or the recipients of Government aid or protection"
The committee's argument for keeping native specimens was that animals once plentiful were becoming almost extinct.
"many kinds of animals that were once plentiful are becoming so scarce as to be considered almost extinct"
The witnesses agreed the building was too small and too frail for the collection.
"The witnesses are unanimous in declaring that the building which now contains the Museum is much too small and too frail to hold securely or to exhibit to advantage so instructive and valuable a collection"
Chairman G. McMicken signed the report on 14 April 1859. The committee unanimously asked the House to consider recommending government aid to Barnett, for the exchange and to finish his new building.
"your Committee unanimously and respectfully make an appeal to your Honorable House to consider the propriety of recommending to the Government the grant of some aid to Mr. Barnett"
"G. McMICKEN, Chairman. Committee Room, Legislative Assembly, 14th April, 1859"
Source: Report of the select committee on the petition of Thomas Barnett, 1859, report pp.2-3 and minutes of evidence pp.5-6.
The new building, 1860
The Barnetts designed and built a new stone building starting in 1858, and it opened in 1860.
"In 1858, the Barnetts designed and built a new stone building for"
"the museum, which opened in 1860"
A notice in the November 1860 Journal of Education for Upper Canada said the museum was nearly complete and would open about the 6th of June.
"the new and beautiful Museum of Mr. Barnett, of Niagara Falls, is now nearly completed, and will be opened for the public about the 6th of June"
The plan was by Mr. Otis, an architect from Buffalo.
"The plan of the building was prepared by Mr. Otis, architect, of Buffalo"
The galleries took their light from the roof, through over 1,800 panes of glass.
"from the top, over 1800 panes of glass having been used"
On top was a promenade, extending over an area of 946 feet, looking out over the rapids, the Horseshoe Falls and the American Falls.
"On the top is a promenade, extending over an area of 946 feet, from which a most delightful panoramic view is presented, embracing the rapids and islands above the Falls, a full view of the Horseshoe and American Falls"
Source: Niagara Falls Museum Papers finding aid, administrative history; Journal of Education for Upper Canada, November 1860, p.170.
Rivals, royalty and a buffalo hunt
The papers hold a letter from the Militia Department to Sidney Barnett about the Prince of Wales' visit, which the finding aid dates to 1860, in brackets.
"Letter from Thomas Wily, Militia Department, to Sidney Barnett regarding the Prince of Wales' visit"
In 1861, by the finding aid's date column, Sidney Barnett wrote to P.M. Van Koughnet about a lease granted to Saul Davis, and the damage it would do to his business.
"Letter from Sidney Barnett to Honourable P.M Van Koughnet regarding a lease granted to Saul Davis and"
"the damage it will do to his business"
The papers hold negatives of letters with P.T. Barnum and Buffalo Bill about arranging a buffalo hunt at the museum.
"letters with P.T Barnum and Buffalo Bill for the arranging of the Buffalo"
"hunt at the Niagara Falls Museum"
In 1872 a letter signed Sidney Barnett, printed in the Saint John Daily Tribune, announced a buffalo hunt at Niagara Falls. It talked of capturing ten or twelve wild buffalo.
"The idea of capturing ten or twelve"
Sidney also served in the militia. The papers hold a negative album of letters to and from him, telegrams from the Fenian Raids among them, and postcards from his time as lieutenant colonel of the 44th Battalion.
"during the Fenian Raids"
Source: Niagara Falls Museum Papers finding aid, series 1; The Daily Tribune, Saint John, 7 May 1872.
Bankruptcy, 1878
After a series of bad business decisions, Barnett filed for bankruptcy on 1 May 1878. The museum and its collections sold at auction for $48,000.
"After a series of bad business decisions, Barnett filed for bankruptcy on 1 May 1878 and the"
"museum and its collections were sold at auction for $48,000"
The buyer was the Barnetts' local rival, Saul Davis.
"Saul Davis (1807-1899)"
The papers keep the broadside that advertised the auction of the museum's buildings and collections.
"Broadside advertising the sale of Niagara Falls Museum buildings and collections at auction"
Thomas Barnett died in 1890. Sydney lived to 1925.
Source: Niagara Falls Museum Papers finding aid, administrative history and series 1.
Across the river and back, 1888 to the late 1950s
In 1888 Davis moved the collection to Niagara Falls, New York.
"In 1888, Davis moved the museum collection to Niagara Falls, New York"
On the American side, a souvenir plate in the papers billed it as the "Oldest Museum in America, Niagara Falls, NY". A postcard shows its fourth building in New York, which the finding aid dates to the 1920s with a question mark.
"Postcard for the fourth building of the Niagara Falls Museum (New York)"
The Sherman family bought the museum in 1942.
"The Sherman family purchased the"
"museum in 1942"
In 1948 Jacob Sherman wrote to Cyril B. Courville about the head of an Egyptian mummy.
"Letters between Jacob Sherman and Cyril B. Courville (College of Medical Evangelists) regarding the"
"head of an Egyptian mummy"
The Shermans brought the museum back to Canada, into a converted five-storey corset factory with a view of the falls. It came back in the late 1950s, per its own press releases, which the finding aid dates to 1959.
"returned it to Canada, where they moved the museum in a converted five story corset factory with a view of Niagara"
"Press releases on the return of the Niagara Falls Museum to Canada"
A typescript in the papers, dated to about 1967, covers the museum's 140th anniversary celebrations.
"Typescript of celebrations for the 140th anniversary of the Niagara Falls Museum"
From 1878 to 1998 the record is mostly folder titles in an archive. They show the moves and the owners. They do not tell the story in between.
Source: Niagara Falls Museum Papers finding aid, administrative history and series 1 and 4.
The late museum
In the 1980s, German Egyptologist Arne Eggebrecht examined the mummy Emory later sent home, while it was still in Niagara Falls, and suggested it could be one of the missing royal mummies.
"examined the mummy in Niagara Falls and suggested it could be one"
"of the missing royal mummies"
In 1985 a German report by W.M. Pahl studied the museum's Egyptian mummies.
In 1991 the Nisga'a Tribal Council wrote asking the museum to repatriate human remains.
"Letter from the Nisga'a Tribal Council requesting repatriation of human remains"
In 1994 the museum's taxidermy polar bear went out onto the ice bridge by the falls.
"the ice bridge by Niagara Falls"
The papers list full size negatives of a mastodon tusk and of what the folder calls the first wax figure shown in America, and printed photographs of a sperm whale skeleton.
"Full size negatives of a mastodon tusk and the first wax figure shown in America"
By 1999, Emory's report says, the Egyptian collection was in a dark and dusty second-floor room above the Daredevil Hall of Fame.
"formerly housed in a dark and dusty second-floor"
"room atop Niagara Fall's Daredevil Hall of Fame"
Source: Niagara Falls Museum Papers finding aid, series 4; Emory Report, 22 July 2002 and 28 June 1999.
The sale, 1998 to 1999
Draft agreements for Golden Chariot Productions Ltd to buy the contents of the museum from Jacob Sherman are dated from July to November 1998 in the finding aid's date column.
"draft agreements between Golden Chariot Productions Ltd and Jacob Sherman to purchase the"
"contents of the Niagara Falls Museum"
In Emory's account, the museum decided to close in 1999, facing declining crowds.
"In 1999, facing declining crowds, the museum decided to close up shop"
The finding aid names the buyer: the Sherman family sold the collections to Golden Chariot Productions in 1999.
"The Sherman family sold the collections to Golden Chariot Productions in 1999"
The sale files hold a list of objects left out of the sale, and letters about preparing to sell the Egyptian mummies.
"Correspondence regarding the preparation to sell the Egyptian mummies"
Copies of the Barnetts' own bills of sale and freight notes are in the same files, likely used to show provenance. The Egyptian collection was posted for sale in 1999.
"bills of sales and freight notes of purchases made by Thomas and Sydney Barnett, likely"
"used as provenance documentation during the sale"
Source: Niagara Falls Museum Papers finding aid, administrative history and series 4; Emory Magazine, Winter 2004.
Atlanta buys, 1999
The asking price was $2 million, with a seven-day deadline. By the end of the week, $1,725,000 had come in, and by the summer of 1999 Emory had bought the collection at full price.
"The asking price was two million dollars. Faced with a deadline"
"At week's end, $1,725,000 had been raised"
The largest single gift was $1 million, from Jim Miller and his wife, Karina Lichirie Miller. The collection took the name the Charlotte Lichirie Collection.
"Charlotte Lichirie Collection of Ancient Egyptian Art"
Emory's June 1999 report described nine coffins and ten mummies, dating from 1000 B.C. to the second century A.D.
"The collection consists of nine coffins and 10 mummies, dating from 1000"
"B.C. to the second century A.D."
In June 1999 the Carlos director, Tony Hirschel, made a conditional promise.
"if this really is Rameses I, there is absolutely no question that we will do the right thing. We will send him home where he belongs"
Emory's own records count the lot three ways: an 83-piece collection in the June 1999 Emory Report, 145 artifacts in Emory Magazine in 2004, and over 150 objects and mummies on the Carlos Museum's current page.
"to buy the 83-piece collection"
"By the summer of 1999, the 145 artifacts"
"In 1999, the Carlos Museum acquired over 150 ancient Egyptian objects and mummies from the Niagara Falls Museum in Ontario, Canada"
Source: Emory Magazine, Winter 2004; Emory Report, 28 June 1999; Carlos Museum, 2003 repatriations page.
Who was he?
One unwrapped mummy had his arms crossed right over left on his chest. For much of Egyptian history, that pose was reserved for royal mummies.
"one unwrapped mummy with his arms crossed right over left on his chest, a pose reserved for royal mummies for much of Egyptian history"
Radiocarbon dating placed him in the New Kingdom, the era of Ramesses I.
"radiocarbon dating of the mummy, which places it in the New Kingdom"
CT scans at Emory Hospital found copious resin in the skull, a practice usually lavished only on royal mummies.
"copious amounts of resin in the skull, a practice usually lavished only on royal mummies"
DNA tests were judged too destructive and too unreliable to run. The evidence was largely circumstantial.
"proof, were deemed too destructive and too unreliable to be"
"undertaken. The evidence was largely circumstantial"
By July 2002, Zahi Hawass had accepted the Carlos Museum's offer to return the mummy. Emory's report put it this way: scholarly evidence suggests he is the missing pharaoh Ramesses I.
"Zahi Hawass has accepted the Carlos Museum's offer to return"
"to Egypt a male mummy that scholarly evidence suggests is that of"
"the missing pharaoh Ramesses I"
Emory Magazine says Hawass was initially quite skeptical about the odds of a pharaoh being found outside Egypt. Then he saw him.
"When I came to the museum in May, I was ten feet away,"
"and I felt he was a king"
"When I saw him, I was sure"
The Carlos itself is careful. It says it could not conclusively identify the Niagara mummy.
"the museum could not conclusively identify the Niagara mummy"
Source: Carlos Museum, 2003 repatriations page; Emory Report, 22 July 2002; Emory Magazine, Winter 2004.
Home, 2003
Earlier that year, on 30 April 2003, the Carlos returned four painted limestone fragments confirmed as coming from the tomb of Seti I.
"the four original painted limestone fragments were returned to Egyptian authorities on April 30, 2003"
The Carlos Museum's exhibition of the mummy drew more than 115,000 visitors before it closed in September 2003.
"drew more than 115,000 before closing in September"
On Friday, 24 October 2003, a gifting ceremony at Hartsfield International Airport sent him home. Hawass was the first to sign the deed of gift, with Carlos director Bonnie Speed.
"to its homeland following a gifting ceremony at Hartsfield International"
"Airport, Friday, Oct. 24"
Hawass called it a gift.
"The Carlos Museum, Atlanta and America have given us a gift"
"Not a small gift, but a big one"
The plan was a display in Cairo, then the Luxor Museum as his final resting place.
The Carlos says why it sent him: it could not exclude the possibility that he was royal.
"Given that the museum could not exclude the possibility of him being a royal mummy"
Source: Carlos Museum, 2003 repatriations page; Emory Report, 3 November 2003.
What the record doesn't say
The founding year is the museum's own. The 1827 date sits in the finding aid's history, no 1827-dated item is listed in the papers, and the 1859 committee said about twenty-five years.
The 1878 dates do not separate. The finding aid lists 1 May 1878 for the bankruptcy, and the broadside sits beside the same date. Which event that day marks is not clear from the finding aid.
The Prince of Wales letter is about his visit, and the finding aid dates the letter to 1860, in brackets. It does not show that he entered the museum. No primary record read places the Prince of Wales, or any royal visitor, in the museum.
The 1872 buffalo hunt was announced. Nothing read says it took place, or who was there.
The 1859 committee asked the House to consider aid. No record read shows that aid was granted.
The return to Canada has no year in the finding aid's history. Its press releases are dated 1959, in brackets, which is why this page says the late 1950s.
The buyer of record in 1999 is Golden Chariot Productions. William Jamieson appears in the papers only in letters about the sale of the Niagara Falls mummies, from 2000 to 2004, and in the entry for an Ontario business licence for the Niagara Falls Museum and William R. Jamieson's business card. Nothing read says he owned Golden Chariot or bought the collection.
"Correspondence between William Jamieson, Karen Bishop, Dr. Peter Lacovara (Michael C."
"Ontario Business License for the Niagara Falls Museum and business card for William R. Jamieson"
The 1991 Nisga'a request is on file. Its outcome is not.
The whale is a sperm whale in the papers. "First wax figure shown in America" is a folder title, not a checked first.
The Egyptian lot has three counts, 83, 145 and over 150, each from a different Emory record. This page gives each with its source.
The name. Emory's records say scholarly evidence suggests Ramesses I. The Carlos says it could not conclusively identify him. No DNA test was done.
Where he is now
The Carlos Museum's page says he is now displayed at the Luxor Museum, in his own private room.
"where he is now displayed at the Luxor Museum in his own private room"
The sources
Niagara Falls Museum Papers, MS Coll 00403A, finding aid (2018), Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto. https://tools.library.utoronto.ca/sites/default/public/finding_aids/niagarafallsmuseum403a.pdf
Report of the Select Committee on the petition of Thomas Barnett, Legislative Assembly of the Province of Canada, 1859. Read from the page images on Canadiana. https://www.canadiana.ca/view/oocihm.9_00359
Journal of Education for Upper Canada, Vol. 13, no. 11, November 1860, "Barnett's Niagara Falls Museum", p.170. https://www.canadiana.ca/view/oocihm.8_06242_155
The Daily Tribune, Saint John, N.B., 7 May 1872, letter signed Sidney Barnett. https://www.canadiana.ca/view/oocihm.N_00716_18720507
Emory Report, 28 June 1999, "In match made in afterlife, Egyptian art comes to Emory". https://news.emory.edu/emory-report-archive/erarchive/1999/June/erjune.28/6_28_99mummies.html
Emory Report, 22 July 2002, "Royal mummy will return to Egypt". https://news.emory.edu/emory-report-archive/erarchive/2002/July/erJuly.22/7_22_02mummy.html
Emory Report, 3 November 2003, "Ceremony marks Ramesses' return home". https://news.emory.edu/emory-report-archive/erarchive/2003/November/Nov3/11_3_03ramesses.html
Michael C. Carlos Museum, Emory University, "2003 Repatriations to the Arab Republic of Egypt". https://carlos.emory.edu/2003-repatriations
Emory Magazine, Winter 2004, "Return of the Mummy", part 2. https://magazine.emory.edu/winter2004/mummy_2.html
This page quotes and links to these documents. Inventory counts are re-typed from the 1859 report, not copied as images.
The episode
Image credits:
- - Photo: Olaf Tausch, CC BY 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/), via Wikimedia Commons
- - Photo: أحمد ناجي (Ahmed Nagy), CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), via Wikimedia Commons
- - Photo: Dennis G. Jarvis, CC BY-SA 2.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/)
- - Photo: Archeologo, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/
- - Photo: Daniel Mayer, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/
- - Photo: Carole Raddato, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/
- - Photo: Wallaa, 'Luxor Museum, Egypt02.jpg', CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
Images are shown with slow pan and zoom motion and a caption overlay.
Public domain and CC0 images courtesy of The New York Public Library, Robert N. Dennis collection of stereoscopic views; Library of Congress; Library and Archives Canada; The Metropolitan Museum of Art (CC0); National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution (CC0); U.S. National Archives; Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto, via Internet Archive; Niagara Falls Public Library; and Gary Todd (CC0).