Weirdly Cited

Can a worm frozen for about 46,000 years wake up and start cloning itself?

Short answer: Researchers recovered living nematodes from Siberian permafrost. The study argues they may have persisted in cryptobiosis for about 46,000 years, but that date comes from plant material in a burrow, not from the worms themselves.

Researchers found viable nematodes in two of more than 300 permafrost samples. The dated worms, a Panagrolaimus species, came from one of those samples: a fossil burrow whose plant material dates to 45,839 to 47,769 years before present. From that, the authors suggest those worms may have remained in cryptobiosis for roughly 46,000 years.

Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it

C1: The paper's age estimate

The authors suggest the nematodes may have remained in cryptobiosis since the late Pleistocene, roughly 46,000 years ago.

have remained in cryptobiosis since the late Pleistocene (~46,000 years)

Source: Abstract.

C2: The date is for plant material

The calibrated radiocarbon age of plant material from the burrow is 45,839 to 47,769 years before present, with a reported 95.4% probability.

95.4% probability

Source: Results.

C3: Nematodes appeared in two samples

Researchers found viable nematodes in two of more than 300 permafrost samples.

Several viable nematode individuals were found in two of the more than 300 studied samples of permafrost deposits

Source: Results.

C4: The burrow was about 40 meters deep

The worms came from a fossil burrow about 40 meters below the surface.

has been taken from the frozen outcrop wall at a depth of about 40 m below the surface

Source: Results.

C5: Arctic gophers left the burrow

The fossil burrow was attributed to arctic gophers, a kind of ground squirrel.

The fossil burrow left by arctic gophers of the genus

Source: Results.

C6: The worm's line continued in a lab

After the animal was revived, its line was cultivated in the lab for more than 100 generations.

The revived animal was cultivated in the laboratory for over 100 generations

Source: Results.

C7: The species reproduces without males

The species reproduces without males.

We found the species to be parthenogenetic

Source: Results.

C8: An earlier nematode record was 39 years

The introduction cites a nematode that remained desiccated in a herbarium specimen for 39 years.

39 years desiccated in an herbarium specimen

Source: Introduction.

C9: Lab C. elegans larvae survived 480 days

In a lab experiment, C. elegans larvae were dried and frozen, with no significant decline in viability after 480 days.

there was no significant decline in viability even after 480 days

Source: Results.

C10: The authors leave the time limit open

The authors ask whether there is an upper limit to how long an individual can remain in cryptobiosis.

This raises the question of whether there is an upper limit to the length of time an individual can remain in the cryptobiotic state

Source: Discussion.

What the study doesn't say

The radiocarbon date is for plant material from the burrow, not for the worm. The roughly 46,000-year timeline for the nematodes is an inference based on that material.

The paper says contamination testing followed earlier published protocols, but gives no details or results. It relies on the burrow coming from undisturbed, never-thawed deposits and cites earlier reviews on the sterility of permafrost sampling.

More than 100 generations describes the worm's lab-cultured line after revival. It does not mean one individual worm lived through all those generations.

The journal's 2023 notice says the article was republished to include previously omitted details concerning taxonomic registration. It does not describe any other change.

The source

Shatilovich et al., "A novel nematode species from the Siberian permafrost shares adaptive mechanisms for cryptobiotic survival with C. elegans dauer larva," PLOS Genetics. Article. Full text. CC BY 4.0.

The journal's 2023 correction notice is linked above. The quoted locations refer to the article sections named above.

The Short

Watch it on YouTube: https://youtu.be/GjTndJspBnA