Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it
C1: Magie's game had a 1904 patent
In 1904, Lizzie J. Magie received a US patent for a game board she named The Landlord's Game.
My invention, which I have designated The landlords game, relates to gameboards
Source: US Patent 748,626, Specification, opening paragraphs.
C3: Railroad spaces charged a fee
The 1904 rules had railroad spaces. Stop on one and you owed five dollars to the railroad.
R. R. represents transportation, and when a player stops upon one of these spaces he must pay five dollars to the R. R.
Source: US Patent 748,626, Rules: Railroad.
C4: A land rule sent players to jail
The patent's board drawing labels some spaces "No Trespassing, Go to Jail." Its rules say a player who stopped on one had to go to jail. The space stood for land held out of use.
Spaces marked No trespassing represent property held out of use, and when a player stops on one of these spaces he must go to jail
Source: US Patent 748,626, Rules: No trespassing.
C5: Magie patented it again under her married name
Elizabeth Magie Phillips filed a second patent for the Landlord's Game in 1923. It was granted in 1924.
My invention, which I call the Landlords game, relates to game boards
ELIZABETH MAGIE PHILLIPS.
Source: US Patent 1,509,312, Specification opening and signature.
C6: The second patent stated the game's purpose
The 1924 patent says the game was meant to show how landlords had an advantage under the land system of the day. It also says a single tax would discourage land speculation.
to illustrate to them how under the present or prevailing system of land tenure, the landlord has an advantage over other enterprises and single tax would discourage land speculation
Source: US Patent 1,509,312, Specification: object of the game.
C8: The court called it a precursor and said Parker Brothers bought it
In a 1982 trademark case, a US appeals court called The Landlord's Game a precursor of Monopoly. It said Parker Brothers purchased the game from Magie around 1934.
A precursor of monopoly, the Landlord's Game, was patented by Mrs. Maggie Elizabeth Phillips of Washington, D.C. in 1904 and again in 1924. Parker Brothers purchased this game from her in 1934 or thereabouts.
Source: Anti-Monopoly, Inc. v. General Mills Fun Group, Inc., Part V, paragraph 19.
C9: The court record says Darrow sold the game as his invention
The same opinion says the game was taught to Charles Darrow, who sold it to Parker Brothers in 1935 while claiming it as his own invention.
The game was taught to Darrow. He sold it to Parker Brothers in 1935, claiming that it was his own invention.
Source: Anti-Monopoly, Inc. v. General Mills Fun Group, Inc., Part V, paragraph 18.
C10: The court rejected the inventor label
The appeals court called the lower court's description of Darrow as the game's inventor or creator clearly erroneous.
Moreover, the court's reference to Darrow as the inventor or creator of the game is clearly erroneous.
Source: Anti-Monopoly, Inc. v. General Mills Fun Group, Inc., Part V, paragraph 17.
What these records don't say
The court calls The Landlord's Game a precursor to Monopoly, not the same game under a new name. Its record says Parker Brothers bought Magie's game. It does not say the company stole it.
The 1904 patent lists the rules. The landlord-advantage and single-tax purpose appears in Magie's 1924 patent. Keep that purpose attached to the later document.
The court record also includes a trademark ruling. Congress replaced the legal test behind that ruling with the Trademark Clarification Act of 1984. The Act does not name the case and does not reopen earlier judgments. It changes trademark law, not the game's history; this page uses the opinion only for its account of the game.
Both patent drawings label No Trespassing spaces "Go to Jail." In the 1904 rules, landing on No Trespassing sends a player to jail, and the space stands for land held out of use.
The sources
- US Patent 748,626, L. J. Magie, "Game-board," patented in 1904. Patent record.
- US Patent 1,509,312, Elizabeth Magie Phillips, "Game board," patented September 23, 1924. Patent record.
- Anti-Monopoly, Inc. v. General Mills Fun Group, Inc., 684 F.2d 1316, No. 81-4281, US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, 1982. Opinion.
- Trademark Clarification Act of 1984, Public Law 98-620, Title I, section 102. Statute PDF.
The patents and federal court opinion are public-domain records. The court opinion's trademark test was superseded by the 1984 Act; this page uses the opinion only for its account of the game's history.
The Short
Watch it on YouTube: https://youtu.be/Y4EV9sC38ZU