Weirdly Cited

Can a limpet's teeth be the strongest natural material when pulled?

Potentially, by tensile strength.

Researchers cut small samples from single limpet teeth and pulled them to failure. They measured between 3.0 and 6.5 GPa, and the authors called the result a possible tensile-strength record in nature.

Here, "strongest" means tensile strength: the stress at which a material breaks when pulled. It does not mean toughest or hardest.

Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it

C1: Small samples broke at 3.0 to 6.5 GPa

Small limpet-tooth samples broke between 3.0 and 6.5 GPa in tensile tests.

"3.0 to 6.5 GPa"

Source: Results.

C2: A possible tensile-strength record

The authors describe the result as a possible record for tensile strength in nature.

"the tensile strength of a limpet tooth is potentially the highest ever recorded in nature, exceeding the strength of spider silk fibres"

Source: Results.

C3: Spider silk in the comparison

Spider silk, the previous record holder in the authors' comparison, reaches up to 4.5 GPa.

"the tensile strength and elastic modulus of spider silk, the material currently consider to be the strongest in nature, can reach values of up to 4.5 and 10 GPa, respectively"

Source: Discussion.

C4: A carbon fibre reached 6.5 GPa

The top of the limpet-tooth range matches a tensile-strength value cited for one high-performance commercial carbon fibre.

"the mechanical strength of the limpet tooth is comparable to that of the strongest man-made fibres, e.g. high-performance Toray T1000G carbon fibres have a tensile strength of 6.5 GPa"

Source: Discussion.

C5: Teeth scrape rock while feeding

Limpets scrape rock with their teeth to feed. The researchers say the teeth need strength and hardness to avoid catastrophic failure.

"these teeth need to be extremely strong and hard to avoid catastrophic failure when rasping over rock surfaces during feeding"

Source: Introduction.

C6: Nanofibres fill most of the tooth

Goethite nanofibres make up about 80% of a mature tooth's volume, set in a protein/chitin matrix.

"consists primarily of mineral nanofibres typically many micrometres in length but only a few tens of nanometres in diameter ... occupy a significant volume fraction of approximately 80% in mature teeth"

Source: Introduction.

C7: Strength barely changed with sample length

The measured strength barely changed as tested samples got four times longer. The authors read this as the material being insensitive to flaws.

"The lack of a significant change in the tensile strength of limpet tooth samples in figure 6 , despite a fourfold increase in the length of the sample, suggest the mineral phase within the limpet tooth is below a flaw tolerant critical size"

Source: Discussion.

C8: About one in ten samples reached failure

Only about 1 in 10 prepared samples was successfully pulled to failure.

"approximately one in every 10 samples prepared being successfully tensile tested to failure in this work"

Source: Material and methods.

C9: Common limpets from Southampton

The researchers tested common limpets, Patella vulgata, collected in Southampton, UK.

"Samples of the limpet Patella vulgata were harvested in Southampton, UK"

Source: Material and methods.

C10: A hybrid compared with organic silk

Limpet teeth are a mineral-plus-organic hybrid. Spider silk is organic, so the authors compare different kinds of material.

"limpet teeth are hybrid materials consisting of an organic and inorganic phase, whereas spider silk is exclusively organic"

Source: Discussion.

What the study doesn't say

The record claim is about tensile strength only. It does not mean limpet teeth are toughest, hardest, or most impact-resistant. The researchers tested small pieces cut from a tooth cusp, not whole teeth. Only about 1 in 10 prepared samples was successfully pulled to failure.

The authors' record claim comes from one lab using one method. We found no newer paper claiming a stronger biological material, but that does not prove none exists. Read this as a claim made with the 2015 paper, not as a current ranking.

The spider-silk comparison is not like-for-like. The tooth is a mineral-plus-organic hybrid; silk is organic. The authors cite spider silk up to 4.5 GPa. The top of the tooth range, 6.5 GPa, matches the figure the authors cite for Toray T1000G carbon fibre.

The tested limpets were Patella vulgata collected in Southampton, UK. Other limpet species were not tested.

The source

Barber AH, Lu D, Pugno NM. Extreme strength observed in limpet teeth. Journal of the Royal Society Interface, 2015.

DOI: 10.1098/rsif.2014.1326.

Full text at Europe PMC. Open-access licence: CC BY.

The Short

Watch it on YouTube: https://youtu.be/Xqtt_qIQ_R8