So the part of the rule that fails is the idea that under five seconds, nothing transfers. Time still mattered: longer contact meant more transfer.
Every number about the study here is from the paper, Miranda and Schaffner, Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 2016. We read its full text. Its supplementary tables were not available to us, so every number here is from the main text.
Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it
C1: The rule, in the paper's words
The paper opens with the popular notion of the five-second rule: food dropped on the floor and left there for under 5 seconds is safe, because bacteria need time to transfer.
"because bacteria need time to transfer."
Source: The paper's Importance paragraph.
C14: People still say it
In September 2026 a post on Reddit's r/NoStupidQuestions put it this way.
"I've heard that if you drop something on the floor and pick it up within five seconds it is still safe to eat."
Source: r/NoStupidQuestions, original post, September 20, 2026. It shows the belief is still around. It is not evidence about bacteria.
C2: Under one second
The authors' answer: some transfer takes place "instantaneously", at the shortest contact time they tested, under 1 second. They write that this disproves the five-second rule.
"Some transfer takes place ... at times of <1 s, disproving the five-second rule."
Source: The paper's Importance paragraph, last sentence.
C3: Four foods, four surfaces, four times
They dropped four foods onto four surfaces and left them there for four contact times.
"four different surfaces (stainless steel, ceramic tile, wood, and carpet), four different foods (watermelon, bread, bread with butter, and gummy candy), four different contact times (<1, 5, 30, and 300 s)"
Source: The paper's Importance paragraph.
C4: 2,560 measurements
With two ways of preparing the bacteria, in a broth or in a buffer, that made 128 scenarios. Each one was run 20 times.
"totaling 128 scenarios. Each scenario was replicated 20 times, totaling 2,560 measurements."
Source: Materials and Methods, transfer between food and surfaces.
C12: The test bacterium
The bacterium was Enterobacter aerogenes, a harmless, food-grade stand-in that attaches to surfaces much like Salmonella does. It was dried onto 5 by 5 cm squares of each surface for 5 hours, and the food was dropped onto it from 12.5 cm.
"A nonpathogenic, food-grade microorganism, Enterobacter aerogenes B199A, with attachment characteristics similar to those of Salmonella, was used for all experiments"
Source: Materials and Methods, bacterial strain and preparation of culture.
C5: Watermelon on stainless steel, under a second
At under 1 second, watermelon dropped on stainless steel took up a mean of 91% of the bacteria. On wood it was 86%. Both figures are for surfaces where the bacteria were prepared in buffer. Percent transfer here is the share of the recovered bacteria that ended up on the food rather than staying on the surface.
"Greater transfer from stainless steel and wood at <1 s was observed (Fig. 2N and O), with mean log percent transfers of 1.96 (91%) and 1.93 (86%) to watermelon, respectively"
Source: Results, inoculated surface to watermelon.
C6: Watermelon most, gummy candy least
Across all the conditions, watermelon took up more bacteria than any other food, about 0.2 to 97%. Gummy candy took up the least, about 0.1 to 62%.
"More bacteria transferred to watermelon ... than to any other food, while the least bacteria transferred to gummy candy"
Source: The paper's abstract.
C9: Carpet
Carpet transferred very little compared with tile and stainless steel. Wood was more variable.
"Carpet has very low transfer rates, compared with those of tile and stainless steel, whereas transfer from wood is more variable."
Source: Discussion, last paragraph.
C10: Not every drop picked up enough to detect
At under 1 second, many drops came out below the detection limit. For bread on carpet, that was 18 and 19 of the 20 replicates, one figure for each way of preparing the bacteria.
"At <1 s, 18/20 and 19/20 replicates were below the detection limit for TSB- and buffer-inoculated carpet samples, respectively"
Source: Results, inoculated surface to bread.
C11: Gummy candy at under a second
Gummy candy did the same. Dropped for under 1 second on surfaces prepared in buffer, on average 19 of 20 replicates were below the detection limit, on any surface.
"On average, 19/20 replicates of gummy candy to any surface at <1 s were below the detection limit"
Source: Results, inoculated surface to gummy candy.
C7: Time still matters
Longer contact meant more transfer.
"Our data clearly show that contact time does influence bacterial transfer, with more bacteria transferred at longer times."
Source: Discussion, paragraph 3.
C8: An oversimplification
The authors write that the five-second rule is "real" in the sense that "longer contact time resulted in more transfer". Their closing line:
"The five-second rule is a significant oversimplification of what actually happens when bacteria transfer from a surface to food."
Source: Discussion, last sentence.
C13: The Rutgers release
Rutgers announced the study in a news release dated September 8, 2016.
"In some instances, the transfer begins in less than one second."
Source: Rutgers University news release, September 8, 2016, first paragraph.
What the paper doesn't say
This page reports what was measured. It is not food-safety advice. The paper puts the risk of illness this way:
"The risk of illness resulting from deciding to consume food that has fallen on the floor depends on factors including the prevalence, concentration, and type of organism; the nature of the food (especially moisture); and the nature of the surface topology; as well as the length of time the food is in contact with the surface."
The bacteria were a harmless stand-in, dried onto small squares of each surface in a lab.
The 91% is a mean for watermelon on stainless steel, at under 1 second, in one arm of the test. It is not the share of germs on any floor.
Under 1 second is the shortest contact time the paper tested.
The source
Miranda RC, Schaffner DW. 2016. Longer Contact Times Increase Cross-Contamination of Enterobacter aerogenes from Surfaces to Food. Appl Environ Microbiol 82(21):6490-6496. doi:10.1128/AEM.01838-16. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5066366/
The article is copyright 2016 American Society for Microbiology, all rights reserved. The quotes here are short excerpts, and we show none of its figures.
Rutgers University news release, September 8, 2016. https://www.rutgers.edu/news/rutgers-researchers-debunk-five-second-rule-eating-food-floor-isnt-safe