Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it
C1: Ten fish took the mirror-mark test
The mirror-mark test was run on 10 cleaner fish.
We conducted the mirror mark tests on 10 cleaner fish
Source: Materials and Methods: Procedure of Mirror Mark Test.
C2: A mark prompted throat-scraping
All 10 fish scraped their throats on the tank bottom after seeing a parasite-like mark there in the mirror.
all fish displayed throat-scraping behaviors on tank substrate after observing in a mirror reflection a mark resembling an ectoparasite, which had been placed on their throat
Source: Results and Discussion: Mirror Mark Test.
C3: Photos looked like territorial intruders
Before mirror exposure, the fish appeared to treat their own photo as an unknown intruder.
Our results demonstrate that mirror-naive fish do not immediately recognize themselves in a photograph but appear to regard their model images as an unknown territorial intruder.
Source: Results and Discussion: Experiment 1.
C4: The face mattered more than the body
After mirror exposure, the face mattered more than the body in the photo. A fish's own face on a stranger's body drew about 2 attacks per 5 minutes; a stranger's face on the fish's own body drew about 19 attacks per 5 minutes.
self-face/unfamiliar fish body (SU after MSR: 2.1 ± 0.4) compared with photographs of the unfamiliar face/self-body (US after MSR: 19.0 ± 4.7
Source: Results and Discussion: Experiment 1.
C5: Photos matched the mirror view
The self-photos were flipped left-to-right to match the view the fish had seen in the mirror.
we reversed the self-face photograph to replicate the perspective that focal fish had been observing in the mirror
Source: Materials and Methods: Experiment 1.
C6: A familiar-neighbor comparison
In a test against a familiar neighbour, fish barely attacked their own photo, with about 1.5 aggressive acts. They showed about 9 aggressive behaviors toward the neighbour's photo.
focal fish aggression did not increase toward the self-photograph (1.5 ± 0.4 SEM) and the frequency of aggressive behaviors was significantly higher toward the photographs of the familiar neighbor (9.1 ± 2.4)
Source: Results and Discussion: Experiment 2.
C7: Six of eight scraped after a self-photo mark
Shown a marked photo of themselves, 6 of 8 fish that had never been marked scraped their throats. The paper reports this as a 75% pass rate for that test.
Six of eight mark-naive focal fish displayed throat-scraping behavior after observing a self-photograph with a mark placed on the throat (passing rate 75%
Source: Results and Discussion: Experiment 3.
C8: Two control photos drew no scraping
No fish scraped its throat at an unmarked photo of itself or a marked photo of a familiar fish.
no fish scraped their throat when observing a self-photograph that was unmarked or when observing a familiar photograph that was marked
Source: Results and Discussion: Experiment 3.
C9: Wild-caught fish in lab tanks
This lab study used 26 wild-caught cleaner fish bought from an aquarium dealer.
We used a total of 26 wild-captured cleaner fish purchased from a commercial ornamental aquarium dealer.
Source: Materials and Methods: Subject Animals and Housing.
C10: Self-awareness remains controversial
The authors say claims about self-awareness in fish remain controversial.
advanced cognitive abilities and self-awareness in nonprimate animals does remain controversial, particularly in fish
Source: General Discussion.
What the study doesn't say
These tests measured attacks and throat-scraping, not thoughts. The authors read the pattern as self-face recognition. That interpretation is contested.
In a published PNAS letter, Alain Morin argued that other mechanisms could explain the results. He also argued that even a mental self-image would show only one narrow part of self-awareness, and that results from heavily handled lab fish cannot be generalized to wild fish. The authors replied that no alternative hypothesis had yet been put forward to test. They also pointed to fish checking the mirror or photo after scraping. On the lab-versus-wild point, they said the fish were wild-caught and shown biologically relevant stimuli, and that whether an animal has mental states does not depend on captivity.
The fish, bluestreak cleaner wrasse (Labroides dimidiatus), were tested in lab tanks, not on a reef. In the photo mark test, 6 of 8 fish scraped their throats after seeing a mark on their own image. That is the result for this test, not a population rate.
Two later studies from the same group examine body-size judgments from photos (2024) and rapid self-recognition (2025). No replication by an outside lab was identified as of 2026-10-03.
The source
Kohda M, Bshary R, Kubo N, Awata S, Sowersby W, Kawasaka K, Kobayashi T, Sogawa S. "Cleaner fish recognize self in a mirror via self-face recognition like humans." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120 (2023): e2208420120.
DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2208420120.
Full text: Europe PMC. Open-access license: CC BY 4.0.
Morin's critique: 10.1073/pnas.2303377120. Authors' reply: 10.1073/pnas.2303923120.
The Short
Watch it on YouTube: https://youtu.be/GcsYcQfHLeU