Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it
C1: A shared ending was rare
Only 1.59% of conversations between strangers ended when both people wanted them to stop.
in a mere 1.59% of the conversations did both conversants want to end at the same time and manage to do so
Source: Study 2, Results.
C2: Exactly one person wanted to stop
About 3 in 10 ended when exactly one person wanted the conversation to stop.
Just 29.37% of conversations ended when one of the conversants wanted them to end
Source: Study 2, Results; authors' OSF code: https://osf.io/8k4aj/.
C3: Most talks ended outside both people's wishes
In 46.83% of the conversations, both people wanted to stop before it ended. In 9.52%, both wanted to keep talking, but the conversation ended anyway.
In 46.83% of the conversations, both conversants wanted the conversation to end before it did, and in 9.52% of the conversations, both participants wanted the conversation to end after it did
Source: Study 2, Results.
C4: People misread their partners
Participants had little idea when their partners wanted the conversation to end.
In short, participants' estimates of their partner's desires were highly inaccurate. Participants had very little idea what their partners really wanted.
Source: Study 2, Results.
C5: The gap was larger than people thought
The difference between partners' wishes was more than twice as large as they believed it was.
Specifically, the discrepancy between participants and their partners was more than twice as large as the participants and their partners thought it was.
Source: Study 2, Results.
C6: The average gap was about half the talk
On average, the difference between the time people wanted and the time they got was roughly half the conversation's length.
the average discrepancy between desired and actual durations was roughly half the duration of the conversation
Source: Abstract.
C7: One person usually wanted to stop first
The authors say one person almost always wants to stop talking before the other.
it appears that when two humans talk, one almost always wants to stop talking before the other one does
Source: Discussion, Why This Happens.
C8: Politeness can hide the exit cue
The authors suggest that people mask their wishes to be polite, which hides information that could help them close the gap.
The irony, of course, is that by masking their desires, conversants are depriving each other of information that might lead them to want the same thing, or at least enable them to bridge the gap.
Source: Discussion, Why This Happens.
C9: The paper covered 932 conversations
One study surveyed people online about their most recent conversation, usually with a friend, partner or family member. The other brought strangers together in a lab.
In two studies of 932 conversations, we asked conversants to report when they had wanted a conversation to end and to estimate when their partner (who was an intimate in Study 1 and a stranger in Study 2) had wanted it to end.
Source: Abstract.
C10: Some stranger pairs hit the time limit
In 57 of 183 pairs, strangers talked for the full 45 minutes and the experimenter stopped them. Those pairs were left out of the analysis.
To our surprise, 57 of the 183 dyads spoke for the full 45 min allotted and the experimenter had to terminate their conversations.
Source: Materials and Methods, Study 2: Data Exclusions.
What the study doesn't say
The 1.59% result came from 126 stranger pairs, after the 57 pairs that reached the 45-minute cap were excluded. That is 2 conversations. The strangers were Harvard study-pool volunteers, average age 23, and the lab result pools three small, nearly identical studies. A shared ending meant the conversation ended at the exact minute both people said they wanted it to end. A near miss counted as a miss. Participants described their wishes afterward, so the measure depends on what they remembered and reported.
The other study was an online survey of 806 people about a recent conversation, mostly with someone close to them. Only one person in each conversation reported, so that study cannot tell when both people wanted to stop together. The paper does not report a preregistration. The authors say it remains to be seen whether the findings generalize.
The source
Mastroianni AM, Gilbert DT, Cooney G, Wilson TD. "Do conversations end when people want them to?" Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 118(10): e2011809118 (2021).
DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2011809118.
Published under the PNAS license. Quote and link only; this page reuses no figures or tables.
The Short
Watch it on YouTube: https://youtu.be/8gZgtJo4KwU