Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it
C1: A study of 14,604 people
A genome-wide association study compared the genes of 14,604 people of European ancestry with whether they said cilantro tasted soapy to them.
we present the results of a genome-wide association study among 14,604 participants of European ancestry who reported whether cilantro tasted soapy
Source: Abstract, Results.
C3: One variant near smell receptor genes
One genetic variant, rs72921001, was significantly linked to tasting soap. It sits in a cluster of smell (olfactory) receptor genes on chromosome 11.
This SNP, rs72921001 (p = 6.4 × 10−9, odds ratio 0.81 per A allele), lies within a cluster of olfactory receptor genes on chromosome 11.
Source: Abstract, Results.
C4: Which version goes with soap
The C version of the variant goes with both tasting soap and disliking cilantro. Each A copy lowers the odds of tasting soap.
The C allele is associated with both detecting a soapy smell and disliking cilantro.
Source: Results and discussion.
C5: A candidate gene, with a "perhaps"
The authors' best guess is OR6A2, a smell receptor that binds several of the aldehydes behind cilantro's smell. They only say "perhaps". The gene is a candidate, not a shown cause.
Among these olfactory receptor genes is OR6A2, which has a high binding specificity for several of the aldehydes that give cilantro its characteristic odor. ... perhaps OR6A2, may be the olfactory receptor that contributes to the detection of a soapy smell from cilantro in European populations
Source: Abstract, Results and Conclusions.
C6: About 0.5% of the variation
Despite the strong statistics, the variant explains only about 0.5% of the variation in who finds cilantro soapy.
Despite the strength of the association of the SNP near OR6A2, it explains only about 0.5% of the variance in perceiving that cilantro tastes soapy.
Source: Results and discussion, heritability paragraph.
C7: A low heritability estimate
The paper's own heritability estimate from common variants is low, 0.087. Its confidence interval includes zero, and the authors call it a lower bound on the true heritability.
We found a low heritability of 0.087 (p = 0.08, 95% CI −0.037 to 0.211). This estimate is a lower bound for the true heritability ... While this calculation does not exclude a heritability of zero
Source: Results and discussion, heritability paragraph.
C8: A twin study put it higher
A twin study that the paper cites estimated the heritability of cilantro dislike at 0.38 for smell and 0.52 for flavour. The authors say the gap could come from the different questions asked, or from genetic factors their scan missed.
In a twin study, the heritability of cilantro dislike has been estimated as 0.38 (confidence interval (CI) 0.22–0.52) for odor and 0.52 (CI 0.38–0.63) for flavor ... This could be due to the differences in phenotypes measured between the two studies, or it could be possible that other genetic factors not detected here could influence cilantro preference.
Source: Background; Results and discussion, heritability paragraph.
C9: Where the soap comes from
The paper puts the soapy note down to aldehydes in cilantro. The (E)-2-alkenals in particular are described as soapy. This is the paper's summary of earlier work, not its own measurement.
This soapy or pungent aroma is largely attributed to several aldehydes present in cilantro. ... the (E)-2-alkenals (mostly (E)-2-decenal and (E)-2-dodecenal) as soapy, fatty, ‘like cilantro,’ or pungent
Source: Abstract, Background.
C11: A weaker effect on liking
Within the paper, the variant replicated in a separate group who said whether they liked cilantro. The effect was weaker there, an odds ratio of 0.92 against 0.81.
The SNP rs72921001 (pdiscovery = 6.4 × 10−9, odds ratio (OR) = 0.81, prepl = 0.0057) ... we see a stronger effect of rs72921001 on soapy-taste detection than on cilantro preference (OR of 0.81 versus 0.92)
Source: Results and discussion.
C13: Not replicated in a Chinese sample
A separate 2020 study, using users of the Chinese consumer genetics company WeGene, did not replicate the variant. In that group, rs72921001 was not significant (p = 0.060).
SNPs reportedly associated with cilantro dislike and soap taste in European populations ... were not replicated in WeGene users: rs72921001 was non-significant (Chi-square test, p = 0.060)
Source: Kang et al. 2020, Section 2.5 (Results). This is a different paper from the 2012 study.
What the study doesn't say
It does not say cilantro tastes like soap because of genes. One variant was linked, and it explains only about 0.5% of the variation in who reports a soapy taste. Most of the difference between people is not explained by it. The paper's heritability estimate does not exclude zero.
The answers are self-reports. People answered the survey question "Does fresh cilantro taste like soap to you?" with yes, no or not sure. The authors say a survey can only approximately measure how people detect or perceive the chemicals in cilantro, and that many people might dislike cilantro at first and later come to appreciate it.
Everyone in the main study was of European ancestry and a customer of the consumer genetics company 23andMe. The authors were 23andMe employees with stock options in the company. A 2020 study of Chinese WeGene users did not replicate the variant, and it gives no sample size for that cilantro test. So the link holds in this European sample; it is not shown for everyone.
The paper does not show how the variant acts. OR6A2 is a "perhaps", and the authors also call a neighbouring gene, OR10A2, a reasonable candidate.
The sources
Eriksson, N., Wu, S., Do, C. B., Kiefer, A. K., Tung, J. Y., Mountain, J. L., Hinds, D. A., and Francke, U. (2012). "A genetic variant near olfactory receptor genes influences cilantro preference." Flavour, 1, 22. DOI: 10.1186/2044-7248-1-22. Read the full text. Licence: CC BY 2.0. Claims C1-C11.
Kang, K., Sun, X., Wang, L., et al. (2020). "Direct-to-consumer genetic testing in China and its role in GWAS discovery and replication." Quantitative Biology, 9(2), 201-215. DOI: 10.1007/s40484-020-0209-2. Claim C13 only. Quote and link only.
We checked Crossref and OpenAlex on 2026-10-11 and found no correction or retraction of the 2012 paper.
The Short
Watch it on YouTube: https://youtu.be/RQ2gGY_gv6o