Weirdly Cited

Buffett paid for a shoe company with Berkshire stock. By 2015 those shares were worth about $5.7 billion.

In 1993 Warren Buffett bought Dexter Shoe for $433 million, paid in Berkshire stock. In his own words, its value went to zero.

Every figure here is Buffett's own, from Berkshire Hathaway's shareholder letters. We read the 2014, 2007, 1993 and 1994 letters in full.

Every claim in the Short, and the sentence behind it

C6: Paid in stock, not cash

The 2007 letter gives the price and how it was paid: $433 million in Berkshire stock, 25,203 Class A shares, for a shoe business bought in 1993.

"a shoe business I bought in 1993 for $433 million in Berkshire stock (25,203 shares of A)"

Source: 2007 letter, PDF p. 8.

C10: The same shares, in the deal-year letter

The 1993 letter, written the year of the deal, records the same share count. The merger date was November 7, 1993.

"we issued 25,203 shares when we acquired Dexter Shoe"

"Includes Dexter's earnings only from the date it was acquired, November 7, 1993."

Source: 1993 letter, the book-value discussion and the footnote to the operating-earnings table.

C2: $433 million, then zero

Berkshire paid $433 million for Dexter. Buffett wrote that its value went to zero, and that it happened "rather promptly".

"Berkshire paid $433 million for Dexter and, rather promptly, its value went to zero."

Source: 2014 letter, PDF p. 26.

C3: What the shares became

Buffett gave the sellers Berkshire stock rather than cash. By his 2014 letter, the shares he used were worth about $5.7 billion. He paid $433 million. The $5.7 billion is what the shares he paid with were worth by 2015.

"I gave Berkshire stock to the sellers of Dexter rather than cash, and the shares I used for the purchase are now worth about $5.7 billion."

Source: 2014 letter, PDF p. 26.

C14: The date on the letter

The 2014 letter is dated February 27, 2015. When he wrote that the shares "are now worth about $5.7 billion", he meant that date, so the $5.7 billion is a 2015 figure.

"February 27, 2015"

Source: 2014 letter, the signature date of the chairman's letter.

C4: The Guinness line

Buffett wrote that, as a financial disaster, Dexter deserves a spot in the Guinness Book of World Records. Those are his words.

"As a financial disaster, this one deserves a spot in the Guinness Book of World Records."

Source: 2014 letter, PDF p. 26.

C11: What he wrote in 1993

In the deal-year letter, Buffett wrote that Dexter needed no fixing. He called it one of the best-managed companies he and Charlie Munger had seen.

"Dexter, I can assure you, needs no fixing: It is one of the best-managed companies Charlie and I have seen in our business lifetimes."

Source: 1993 letter, the section on Dexter Shoe.

C1: The most gruesome

In the 2014 letter he named Dexter the most gruesome of his mistakes. When Berkshire bought it in 1993, he wrote, it had a terrific record.

"The most gruesome was Dexter Shoe. When we purchased the company in 1993, it had a terrific record"

Source: 2014 letter, PDF p. 26.

C5: What went wrong

His stated cause was foreign competition. Dexter's competitive strengths evaporated, and he wrote that he did not see it coming.

"Its competitive strengths, however, were soon to evaporate because of foreign competition. And I simply didn't see that coming."

Source: 2014 letter, PDF p. 26.

C8: The worst deal, to date

In the 2007 letter, dated February 2008, he called Dexter the worst deal he had made so far.

"To date, Dexter is the worst deal that I've made."

Source: 2007 letter, PDF p. 8.

C7: The same shares, valued in 2008

The 2007 letter counted the cost at an earlier date. In February 2008 he put the cost to Berkshire shareholders at $3.5 billion, not $400 million, because he paid in stock. His $400 million there is the $433 million, rounded.

"That move made the cost to Berkshire shareholders not $400 million, but rather $3.5 billion."

Source: 2007 letter, PDF p. 8.

C9: 1.6% of Berkshire

In the same letter he wrote that he gave away 1.6% of Berkshire, then valued at $220 billion, to buy a worthless business.

"I gave away 1.6% of a wonderful business"

Source: 2007 letter, PDF p. 8.

The $3.5 billion and the $5.7 billion are the same 25,203 shares, valued at two dates: February 2008 and February 2015.

What the letters don't say

They don't say Dexter went bankrupt or closed. They say its value went to zero, and the 2007 letter calls it a worthless business.

The $5.7 billion is a 2015 figure. We don't give a value for those shares today.

The worst-deal line is from 2008, and it starts with a qualifier: "To date, Dexter is the worst deal that I've made." In 2015 he called Dexter the most gruesome of his mistakes.

This page is company history from Berkshire's own letters. It is not investment advice.

The source

Berkshire Hathaway Inc. shareholder letters: 2014 letter (dated February 27, 2015), PDF p. 26; 2007 letter (dated February 2008), PDF p. 8; 1993 chairman's letter, the section on Dexter Shoe. Berkshire's letters index.

Berkshire's letters index says the letters include copyrighted material reproduced with permission. The quotes here are short excerpts.

The Short